 
Business Ownership May Be Best Way to Insure Comfortable Retirement
By Michael McDermott
People give all sorts of reasons for
wanting to start their own business. Often they have to do with the desire
to gain more control over their lives and the chance to remove limitations
on their upward earning potential. Now there is another good reason for
people to become entrepreneurs, even on a part-time basis, and that is to
guarantee their ability to live a comfortable life in retirement.
By anyone's standards, Ralph and Sylvia Turco of Livonia, Mich., have
led long and fulfilling lives. Sylvia, 69, has been a successful writer,
editor, radio and TV personality. Ralph, 84, has been a high-ranking police
officer, a politician and a merchant. They have launched and grown several
successful entrepreneurial ventures and hobnobbed with the elite of show
business and politics.
Certainly, they are of an age where they might be expected to retire
into obscurity. Just as certainly, they could survive more than comfortably
in such an existence. Yet each chooses to continue working. Sylvia is currently
working on a book about women in dysfunctional relationships, and she and
Ralph together manage a variety of entertainment ventures including national
beauty pageants.
"We are not comfortable with the idea of retiring," Sylvia
states simply. "We have friends who've retired, and they seem to do
nothing."
Sociologists and economists say that Ralph and Sylvia Turco may well
represent the new face of retirement in the 21st century. While their continued
involvement in work-based activities into their 70s and 80s may not be typical
of their generation, it promises to become much more common among members
of the generations behind them.
Many entrepreneurs see business ownership as a retirement investment. |
While the popular perception of retirement among U.S. workers has long
been a sort of pleasant swan song for the American Dream, the reality of
retirement in the future -- even the present -- is quite different. With
the average retirement age heading upward and the resources available from
government programs such as Social Security moving in the opposite direction,
more and more Americans are likely to continue working well into their 60s
and 70s.
Some, like the Turcos, will work because they want to, but a much greater
number will simply have no choice. When two economists polled 1,200 baby
boomers two years ago for a Merrill Lynch-sponsored study called "Saving
the American Dream," a reduced expectation of future government assistance
in retirement was clearly reflected in the survey responses.
Asked if they thought the government had made financial promises to their
generation that it would not be able to keep, 84.9% said yes. Asked if they
thought future retirees would face a personal financial crisis 20 years
hence, 85.8% said they did.
CHANGES AHEAD
Those expectations are setting the stage for some important changes in
the traditional concept of retirement. According to the Bureau of Labor
Statistics, the median retirement age dropped precipitously from 1950 to
1990 -- down to 63 from 67. But recent studies indicate that decline has
bottomed out and begun to reverse itself.
So here's the situation: A worker earning $50,000 the year before retirement
can expect Social Security -- at full benefit levels -- to replace just
37% of that income. Currently, pensions make up just 20% of the typical
retiree's income, and the average 65-year-old can expect to live at least
another 17 years.
Given all the above factors, it seems a sure bet that continued work
into their 60s and 70s will be a part of many baby boomers' future.
In his book, "The Retirement Myth," journalist Craig Karpel
paints a grim picture of millions of baby boomer "dumpies" (destitute
unprepared mature people) eking out a hand-to-mouth existence rather than
swatting golf balls in the Florida sun. However, he also acknowledges that
this scenario is not preordained to occur.
Like many experts in this field, Karpel envisions work beyond traditional
retirement age as the key. "For us, quitting paid work in one's sixties
and turning to a life of pure play, now a virtually universal middle class
expectation, will become what it previously was in America and still is
in most of the world: a dream for many, a goal for some, attained by few,"
he writes.
The drop in the average retirement age has bottomed out and is on the rise. |
Actually, says Dallas Salisbury, president of the Employee Benefit Research
Institute, if that type of retirement has been a "universal middle
class expectation," it has been a very unrealistic one.
"The vast majority of defined benefit retirement plans (the type
generally offering the most generous pay-outs) have always been offered
only at about the 7,000 largest companies in America, and there has been
very little shift in that regard," he says. "The [pure play] retirement
scenario has never had real relevance except to the top 20% of earners."
Despite the flawed vision of the quality of retirement commonly held,
expectations of a lower retirement age have been met consistently, with
the median retirement age dropping by four years since the end of World
War II.
Many economists and sociologists have been predicting further drops in
that median age through the first decade of the next century, but one voice
that has been consistently contrarian in that regard has recently been proved
correct.
The latest data show that the decline in median retirement age is clearly
over," says Richard Burkhauser, an economist at Syracuse University's
Maxwell School, the nation's leading public policy graduate school. "From
1985 to 1993, the number of men actively participating in the labor force
increased by more than a full percentage point, and the number of 65-year-olds
working has held steady at 30.5%, halting a four-decade decline."
Burkhauser serves on a technical committee of the 1995 Advisory Council,
a group of public-and private-sector experts convened to give advice to
the Social Security Administration. With the retirement age at which workers
can collect full Social Security benefits already scheduled to go up to
67, the Advisory Council is poised to recommend it be raised even higher,
he says.
WORKING LONGER
"The clear signal from the federal government is that people are
going to be expected to work longer, and that signal will make it more expensive
for private firms to fund the kind of early retirement programs that have
helped fuel the drop in retirement age," Burkhauser says.
Since the average baby-boomer household is saving only about a third
of what it will need to live comfortably in retirement, continued work beyond
traditional retirement age by many Americans seems guaranteed. The Turcos'
son, Michael, in fact, is preparing for just that eventuality.
Michael Turco is not counting on much help from government programs in
his retirement scenario. "I think I'll have to rely mainly on myself,"
says the 35-year-old Rancho Palos Verdes, Calif., computer specialist. "Planning
it out that way is certainly the safest route. Society has changed so much
over the past 30 years. I have no idea what the world will be like in another
30."
With a wife and two young children, Michael has already experienced firsthand
the vagaries of corporate life in the 1990s. Despite playing a key role
in Mattel Toys Inc.'s computerization efforts from 1988 to 1994, he found
himself downsized out of a job when the company merged with Fisher-Price
Inc. Although he is thriving as a self-employed consultant, the experience
was an important wake-up call.
The Social Security Administration may increase eligibility age for benefits. |
Like many of his contemporaries, Michael Turco expects to continue working
well beyond traditional retirement age. Accommodating the prospect of some
76 million graying baby boomers with similar expectations of continued,
meaningful employment may require some radical changes in society. Some
feel the key will be providing access to relevant training.
The American Association of Retired Persons (which, despite its name
and reputation as a fierce defender of the retirement life style, advocates
the right of older people to continue working) has published a report called
"Lifelong Learning: Investing in People as Social Insurance."
In it, AARP calls for the use of Social Security trust funds as a source
of job training loans for aging workers.
The organization has also broadened its definition of retirement to include
"phased retirement, retirement from one job to another and new careers."
Its financial planning guide for soon-to-be retirees bluntly acknowledges
that, "Many people plan to work in retirement, and this may be an idea
you want to adopt."
Older workers have many skills that translate well to owning a business. |
Since the rising eligibility age for Social Security will make it increasingly
expensive for companies to push out older workers, some can expect to continue
doing the same jobs they do today.
Even if they stay in the same line of work, however, many employees will
begin looking for alternatives to full-time employment, especially as they
get into their mid-60s and beyond, says Roger Herman, a futurist, consultant
and author of "Turbulence: Challenges and Opportunities in the World
of Work."
Flex-time, part-time and consulting arrangements will have increasing
appeal, both to aging workers and their employers. A growing number of older
people will rely on multiple sources of income, such as home-based businesses
and one or more part-time positions.
"Employers will be able to tap into a trained, reliable, mature
work force on an as-needed basis," Herman points out. "They won't
have to pay for traditional benefits packages, and they won't have to come
up with the kind of make-work activities often needed to justify a full-time
position."
For older workers interested in pursuing new challenges, Herman says
there will be no shortage of opportunities. Among them are the traditional
service industries from retailing to hospitality. He also predicts a boom
in information services and health care and the emergence of an entire new
class of service jobs targeted to meeting the needs of younger, two-income
families.
NEW OPPORTUNITIES
"One of the positions we see opening up in the near future is a
neighborhood concierge," Herman says. There will also be increasing
demand for instructors at community colleges and continuing education programs.
Partially employed older workers will maintain a life-long interest in learning
about both work-related and leisure topics, he predicts.
Many service companies value older employees for their strong work ethic
and respect for authority, but the coming wave of boomer retirees will raise
new challenges for employers, says Charles Schewe, a principal in the consulting
firm Lifestage Matrix Marketing and a professor of marketing at the University
of Massachusetts at Amherst's Graduate School of Management.
"There will be a different perspective on the need for self-fulfillment
from work when the boomers hit this stage," says Schewe. "The
kind of work they will find fulfilling will have to have some quality-of-workplace-life
aspects that present-day retirement-age people are not demanding."
The baby boomers are less work-focused than the generation of workers who
grew up during the Great Depression, Schewe says. "They place much
greater value on things such as recreational opportunities, quality of life
and leisure time. There is no reason to believe those attitudes will change
as they age."
Older workers staying on in their jobs for longer periods of time will
not necessarily mean fewer opportunities for younger workers. Rather, employers
will begin concentrating on finding qualified workers with the experience,
attitude and education to get the job done, says Herman. "Age will
become irrelevant. Young people are going to have more opportunities to
pursue a number of different career directions, and they will do so on a
continuing basis," he suggests.
Insuring a comfortable retirement will be a strong motivator for entrepreneurs. |
Economically, this new concept of retirement could have dramatic impacts
on spending patterns, but it is difficult to predict just what they might
be.
Some economists paint a rosy picture should the economy sustain a decade
of reasonable growth early in the next century, when the leading edge of
the baby boom turns 65.
One final factor that cannot be discounted is the resourcefulness and
ingenuity of retirees themselves. The motivation to find a way to have a
comfortable retirement is a very strong one, and the baby boomers are the
most educated generation in the history of the world. Many are likely to
find ingenious ways to prosper in their later years, and one popular way
will be business ownership.
|